Showing posts with label Goldman Sachs. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Goldman Sachs. Show all posts

Thursday, September 2, 2010

Good Move: Bess Joffe to Goldman


Now here is a smart move by Goldman Sachs to address its impaired reputation and strained shareholder relationships. The firm has hired Bess Joffe as vice president-governance, and she will join the firm's investor relations team starting on Oct. 4.

That's none too soon, as shareholder forces are already starting to mobilize for the 2011 proxy vote. Crain's New York Business has just called the firm "target No. 1 for activist investors looking to shake up corporate boards."

So Bess will have her work cut out for her. But from my recent experience in publishing her in Directors & Boards, I see her being a dynamic new asset for the firm in constructively engaging with investors on behalf of Goldman's board and management.

She will be joining Goldman from Hermes Equity Services Ltd. in London. Here is her bio note that I ran earlier this year: "She joined Hermes in 2005 to work on corporate governance and responsible investment in the Americas. In her role, she actively engages at the board level with underperforming companies that are fundamentally sound but have a variety of strategic, financial or governance issues, with the objective of helping improve long-term financial performance."

Bess was a forceful contributor on a panel discussion that Charles Elson and I organized and conducted at the Weinberg Center for Corporate Governance at the University of Delaware (where the above photo was taken). That discussion, held in November 2009, addressed the pros and cons of separating the chairman and CEO positions. The resulting article, titled "The Great Divide," appeared in the First Quarter edition of Directors & Boards.

Here is a telling comment she made in the article: "We at Hermes are responsible for protecting the interests of long-term shareholders. We recognize that different boards face different situations at different times. But shareholders need to understand with much more specificity why boards have made particular decisions at a particular time. Right now that information is really lacking."

My bet: With Bess Joffe's experience as an investor advocate, starting in October Goldman shareholders, and the financial markets in general, will start getting much more clarity into the firm's governance and board conduct. Her hiring is a signal that Goldman is getting quite serious about its needs in this area.

Friday, July 16, 2010

Goldman: What Might Have Been


There is no surprise that Goldman settled with the SEC yesterday. The firm would have been foolish not to, and the sooner the better. Two surprises did come out of the settlement, one minor and one major:

• The minor surprise was the settlement amount of $550 million. I thought the SEC would peg the fee to get out of the penalty box at $1 billion, a number that would memorialize for the ages the whole reason it brought its case against Goldman. In my opinion, at its core this case was never really about Abacus. It was a statement by the SEC that the ethos of Wall Street, from the head firm (Goldman Sachs) down through the tentacles of every trading outfit, was poisoning the capital markets and jeopardizing the soundness of the economic system. The lower number dialed down that statement, but the SEC accomplished its intended and appropriate "come to Jesus" moment.

• The major surprise was that Lloyd Blankfein kept his hold on the firm. "Some had speculated the legal dustup would at least cost him his chairmanship," noted New York Times reporter Graham Bowley in his account of the leadership implications of the SEC deal for Goldman.

I never expected that the SEC would force Blankfein out. I did anticipate that, in allowing him to stay on as CEO, the agency would insist on the firm having an independent nonexecutive chair. This would not have to be a permanent split, but long enough — perhaps two years — for the firm to rebuild its battered reputation.

This is the action that would have made a substantial statement to a nation still suffering from the ill effects of a Wall Street gone amuck that the leading firm in finance is indeed serious and committed about finding its "true north" again.

I use that phrase deliberately, because here is the thing — Goldman Sachs has sitting on its board the one person who could step into the nonexecutive chair role and get the firm perceived as being regrounded in a sense of ethical leadership. That person is Bill George (pictured). Mr. "True North" himself.

A passing glance at Bill's career — his business accomplishments and contributions to the thought leadership of "doing the right thing" — would persuade that Goldman had taken a decisive step in addressing its defaced image. That should have been a desired outcome of the settlement, one that the firm fully embraced — meaning that Goldman might have proactively taken this action, with or without SEC prompting. It certainly could live with shared leadership, as there is a legacy of shared leadership (albeit insiders) of the firm, as witness the eras when John Whitehead and John Weinberg shared the reins, and then when Robert Rubin and Stephen Friedman were co-leaders.

So, a major surprise in the Goldman SEC settlement, and a major missed opportunity for the firm to restore a sacred reputation for trustworthy and far-sighted leadership.

Thursday, April 22, 2010

Weinberg's Words


So, Lloyd Blankfein thinks the SEC's attack on Goldman Sachs is politically motivated and is telling clients, according to today's Financial Times, that it will "hurt America."

Sidney Weinberg must be spinning in his partner's office in the great beyond.

Weinberg is a renowned past leader of Goldman Sachs & Co. He joined the firm in 1907 and became chairman in 1930, heading it until 1969. His son John joined the firm in 1950, eventually rising like his father to head the firm as co-chair with John Whitehead from 1976-1984 and as sole chair until 1990.

Weinberg pere died in 1969, but he was the author of a cover story in the Summer 2003 edition of Directors & Boards. How that happened was that we got our hands on a remarkable speech that he delivered in 1949 to the Harvard Business School Club of Cleveland. He titled his talk, "The Functions of a Corporate Director." Why this speech is remarkable was the very reason I made it the cover story — I wanted to bring to a modern-day audience a "present at the creation" document that put forward how a public company board of directors needs to conduct itself for a progressive era of governance. It was everything the most assertive activist investor would want to hear.

I think of Sidney Weinberg, nicknamed "Mr. Wall Street" by the New York Times for his vast influence in his day on the banking business, spinning madly at Blankfein's assertion that the SEC is "hurting America" because here is what the distinguished banker warned in his 1949 speech:

"One must remember that every time a national corporation takes a step which is, or appears to be, against the public interest, it reacts on all corporations and is detrimental to our whole system of private enterprise."

The message, then, from one former Goldman chairman to his present counterpart: You are right about America being hurt, but are very wrong about the reason — it's not the attack on Goldman but what Goldman may have done to draw out the attack dogs.

Friday, April 16, 2010

Wasted Real Estate


I started reading the Wall Street Journal in the 1970s, when I first got into the business world. The long-running joke was that the loneliest job in the newspaper business was photo editor of the Wall Street Journal, because the paper rarely, and I mean almost never, ran a photograph.

As the WSJ evolved its page design (still an unhappy development for us diehard business-news junkies), that joke has been long retired. But would someone please tell me why photos of highway accidents in California and crime victims in Chicago, both of which appeared in the WSJ this week, are now taking up important real estate in this bible of business news?

I don't get it. There is so much of consequence happening in the corporate and financial markets that needs continuing, detailed examination — not the least of which are complex narratives like today's lodging of fraud charges by the government against Goldman Sachs. For the paper to squander even the slightest attention on grisly car wrecks and random street crime is ludicrous.

I don't suppose under Rupert Murdoch's proprietorship we can hope the photo editor's job is going to get a little more lonely again. But maybe the job could be more businesslike in its photo selection. Give us more of what board members need to add to their understanding of what's going on on Main Street and Wall Street.

Thursday, February 18, 2010

Director Resignations: An Enigma Wrapped in a Mystery


I got a call today from a New York Times reporter asking me about the decision by Ruth Simmons not to stand for re-election to the board of Goldman Sachs. Was there anything special to read into this move, he inquired.

I got the call because Directors & Boards ran a profile piece in our Spring 2000 issue on Simmons, then the president of Smith College, for getting the prestige invitation to join the post-IPO Goldman board. Our article reported that she turned down the first invite from Hank Paulson but, as our writer Kelly McCarthy noted, "Traditionally, what Goldman Sachs wants, Goldman Sachs gets," and that was true of the firm's intent to have Simmons join the board.

I made three points to the Times:

• Public announcements of director resignations or decisions to not stand for re-election are almost invariably couched in the most conservative and constructive terms, such as a desire to redirect precious time and energy to doing other things. In other words, running to something rather than running away from something. And that indeed seems to be the case with the Simmons' announcement, since it reads that she is stepping off the board "as a result of increasing time commitments associated with her position as president of Brown University."

• Since we are not a fly on the wall of the boardroom, it would be the rankest of speculations to attribute any other motives to her decision.

• Board resignations can indeed serve the purpose of being a "protest move" by a director, but unless it is accompanied by some candid statement of what may have prompted it, it serves as an ineffectual rejoinder to management's actions and squanders an opportunity to prompt a change in behavior, personnel, policies, or whatever the source of the director's dissatisfaction.

I can understand the NYT's interest. There is some suspicious smoke. Goldman Sachs is a churning furnace of bad publicity. No director likes to be on the board of a company that is one giant piñata for savage press and public contempt, because they too can then become a piñata.

This seems to have been happening with Simmons, as per this critical piece from the Brown Daily Herald on her Goldman directorship as it pertains to her Brown presidency, and this critique of Simmons by Reuters blogger Felix Salmon. Three days after the publication of both of these articles on Feb. 9 came Simmons' announcement of her departure from the Goldman Sachs board. Interesting timing, no?

But, again, if there is a deeper message in this director's resignation, it is likely to remain unconveyed. A director resignation can mean many things. Mostly, such a move is utterly enigmatic. And useless as a tool for change.

Friday, October 24, 2008

John Whitehead, Mensch


I always enjoy a Yiddish expression dropped into business conversation. My paternal grandfather spoke Yiddish, which may be one reason why the language resonates with me. 

I'm just back from the National Association of Corporate Directors (NACD) annual conference. There is much fruit for future blog posts to come out of the sessions and speeches. Here is the first.

The NACD, in a brilliant decision, presented its Ken West Lifetime Achievement Award to John Whitehead. John's credentials and accomplishments would not even fit into a supersized blog entry. Suffice for current purposes to say that John is a former co-chair of Goldman Sachs and one of the most renowned if not revered banker-businessmen of our times.

In a buildup to John's stepping on stage to be handed the award, a short film was played that showed several friends and colleagues lauding the honoree. One was Josh Weston, former head of Automatic Data Processing Inc. The accolades were piling up to the ceiling of the JW Marriott ballroom. 

Finally, as the tape wound down, Weston admitted that there was no word in the English language that could capture the essentialness of John Whitehead. The only word, he said, that could do justice to John was this: "Mensch."

Josh had it right, and the 700-strong crowd knew it. They jumped to their feet to applaud what a stand-up guy (a lame interpretation of the Yiddish salute) John Whitehead is. Our congrats to John, with whom we did a cover story interview in our Summer 2005 edition, on this well-deserved recognition.